The Witcher is facing intense backlash as Season 4 continues to divide longtime viewers and new audiences alike. The Netflix fantasy series, once celebrated for its strong performances, is now at the center of heated discussions. Most of the criticism stems from the major changes introduced this season, especially the recasting of Geralt. Additionally, complaints about weak writing, and deviations from the source material have fueled the conversation online. As a result, the show’s reception has noticeably shifted, and fans are more vocal than ever.
Recasting Geralt Ignites the Strongest Reaction
The biggest controversy this season began with the departure of Henry Cavill. His portrayal of Geralt of Rivia was widely praised, and viewers connected deeply to his grounded, stoic performance. When Liam Hemsworth stepped into the role, expectations were high. However, many fans argue that the character now feels different, both in presence and tone. Despite Hemsworth’s efforts, the transition has been difficult for the audience. This change alone created a wave of criticism even before the season premiered.
Production Quality and Fan Frustration Add More Fuel
Fans have also pointed out that certain visual effects and fight choreography appear less polished compared to earlier seasons. Though Netflix continues to support the show, the overall feel of the new episodes has raised concerns about production direction. Combined with shifting character arcs and lore changes, these issues have led to a broader sense of frustration within the fandom.
Despite the backlash, the cast has addressed the situation with professionalism. Some cast members have spoken openly about the pressure they face, while others have encouraged viewers to give the new direction a chance. Yet, with conflicting opinions everywhere, the series remains in one of its most challenging moments.
As The Witcher navigates its current backlash, its future depends on how audiences respond to the remaining seasons. Fans still hope for improvement, and many believe the story can recover if handled with care. For now, the series stands at a crossroads, with Season 4 sparking important conversations about adaptation, character identity, and creative evolution.
